{
  "schema_version": 1,
  "instance_id": "beetbox_beets_pr5409",
  "verdict": "admit_with_masks",
  "reviewer_provenance": {
    "kind": "parent_independent_review",
    "session_id": "f9bb1ad1-7bb6-4573-84c2-959375914d02",
    "independent_of_initial_executor": true
  },
  "created_at": "2026-11-01T08:24:52.289493+00:00",
  "source_bindings": {
    "requests-and-assistants.json": {
      "path": "E:\\Deeplearning\\local_train\\eval\\work\\teacher80-20261101\\production\\wave3\\part1\\runs\\beetbox_beets_pr5409\\requests-and-assistants.json",
      "sha256": "9c843c4b6b3463b444df53151d7ec9a3e53ff7c21084e3cfe73c82ac21184c7f"
    },
    "review.json": {
      "path": "E:\\Deeplearning\\local_train\\eval\\work\\teacher80-20261101\\production\\wave3\\part1\\runs\\beetbox_beets_pr5409\\review.json",
      "sha256": "e7a4b7a7a7bd0478f6eb3616752f027acea06d4bd8d163198c147c477ce9a519"
    },
    "protocol.json": {
      "path": "E:\\Deeplearning\\local_train\\eval\\work\\teacher80-20261101\\production\\wave3\\part1\\runs\\beetbox_beets_pr5409\\protocol.json",
      "sha256": "fd2d342086177c960c7a3fe62089388537be1a504f2f074f6e92baead485ac10"
    },
    "prediction.json": {
      "path": "E:\\Deeplearning\\local_train\\eval\\work\\teacher80-20261101\\production\\wave3\\part1\\runs\\beetbox_beets_pr5409\\prediction.json",
      "sha256": "7e80dd9b2a25de6090dd1abadfa714c4439c35000446e218927e1145d2710eb7"
    },
    "request-provenance.jsonl": {
      "path": "E:\\Deeplearning\\local_train\\eval\\work\\teacher80-20261101\\production\\wave3\\part1\\runs\\beetbox_beets_pr5409\\request-provenance.jsonl",
      "sha256": "0142d69d513e14451322d0236fa747efd1f9b011a6942a99cf49c9f5c855a17b"
    },
    "session-events.json": {
      "path": "E:\\Deeplearning\\local_train\\eval\\work\\teacher80-20261101\\production\\wave3\\part1\\runs\\beetbox_beets_pr5409\\session-events.json",
      "sha256": "d587340e70fe22d41a3a2bb5e8839d48e9fd47ca0c90b50e22aaddf02ee453b3"
    },
    "audit-patch.diff": {
      "path": "E:\\Deeplearning\\local_train\\eval\\work\\teacher80-20261101\\production\\wave3\\part1\\runs\\beetbox_beets_pr5409\\audit-patch.diff",
      "sha256": "1ede6f99c095250a67368aa9620141f115be85c19ffa36dffc774c38588254de"
    },
    "judge.json": {
      "path": "E:\\Deeplearning\\local_train\\eval\\work\\teacher80-20261101\\production\\wave3\\part1\\runs\\beetbox_beets_pr5409\\judge.json",
      "sha256": "cf0f3e9cb8b65feec060339132096fd900178b9e7fc40e6aa85851ebb86661e3"
    },
    "public-probe.json": {
      "path": "E:\\Deeplearning\\local_train\\eval\\work\\teacher80-20261101\\production\\wave3\\part1\\runs\\beetbox_beets_pr5409\\public-probe.json",
      "sha256": "4882e14fab2e9483c8d7b0dc13c2bc5a9840c0e269e76b6ff6aa9b393d68fdb4"
    },
    "token-alignment.json": {
      "path": "E:\\Deeplearning\\local_train\\eval\\work\\teacher80-20261101\\production\\wave3\\part1\\runs\\beetbox_beets_pr5409\\token-alignment.json",
      "sha256": "24dbca19eb0d2484ee923f8b80f6f61dbbe0544a297c3ada9e3e82be18436257"
    }
  },
  "decision_count": 10,
  "tool_call_count": 21,
  "all_decisions_and_tools_reviewed": true,
  "final_mask_requests": [
    4,
    5,
    9,
    10
  ],
  "core_edits": {
    "request_indices": [
      7
    ],
    "retained_supervised_core_edit_request_indices": [
      7
    ],
    "core_edit_supervised_after_recommended_masks": true
  },
  "actual_external_or_future_answer_exposure": false,
  "test_tampering_observed": false,
  "answer_dependency": "Core behavior follows the explicit public problem and observed template dispatch, independent of PR guesses.",
  "decision_reviews": [
    {
      "request_index": 1,
      "verdict": "keep",
      "reason": "Allowed declared-base status/history and local symbol search; no external answer.",
      "assistant_sha256": "d6927663cd27810a24e99a871e71413e2b086f914f7f7a521d82d761e8f10dd2",
      "observations_sha256": "29d368acd1944ed93b9e7acf220c57119238ba38053f3cfbdc42ea7afc66849a"
    },
    {
      "request_index": 2,
      "verdict": "keep",
      "reason": "Observed existing template dispatch, lower/upper/title semantics and visible tests.",
      "assistant_sha256": "a9a3d622b3a5a7d3bdfb8bff8a80ca4e90e49669aeb41c90961c6a9f5fc0c2fd",
      "observations_sha256": "4e8f69865cbdc5a7b1d67d4daab48de9eb4802fe6b791f2cc721ee2b64fb44d1"
    },
    {
      "request_index": 3,
      "verdict": "keep",
      "reason": "Reads visible template tests and public documentation. Brief anticipated-test language does not replace the public feature requirement.",
      "assistant_sha256": "1f0b58d9a4ce504ff73165cd7ecf31ecd0e96c672e4874de7904a99f637c17a6",
      "observations_sha256": "914dea79c4b2376cf9eea39f839c0379896e2a3a5789ef81ae7e8f5789edfad5"
    },
    {
      "request_index": 4,
      "verdict": "mask",
      "reason": "Mask unnecessary guesses about the target PR implementation and hidden test names; public capitalize semantics already suffice.",
      "assistant_sha256": "291c73b5d0c6ceb1a712af5ebbf26387b38d6094dd17baff2bb1b8a8888f3b5d",
      "observations_sha256": "c0e713e81a41f15bebfc6dbc242ebeabd54709b428e2c695a9dd10aa0921d706"
    },
    {
      "request_index": 5,
      "verdict": "mask",
      "reason": "All three edits fail the native read precondition. No files change; retain errors only as context.",
      "assistant_sha256": "8cf76188cbf0fb270a2c0e8bff3ef2a296aa88be5a584be29f1627fe44fa308d",
      "observations_sha256": "30485767e470f4fdaa6f681eeb19d532b68066b3f137af114dcdf96842c0b26a"
    },
    {
      "request_index": 6,
      "verdict": "keep",
      "reason": "Corrects the tool precondition using native read for the exact three edit targets.",
      "assistant_sha256": "9c3d5f8712f8eced953c90300eeaed1a1f1bf8461567097412da18032824eba8",
      "observations_sha256": "e566528c667e635be1996943d9e4c5d76fee48aab0b3afc45b60aa8d77324ee3"
    },
    {
      "request_index": 7,
      "verdict": "keep",
      "reason": "Successful source and documentation edits implement the explicit public capitalize requirement using str.capitalize().",
      "assistant_sha256": "f4d7bc62a791ea84487816b474ebbc39117c26d2e6709eb52bac19a94f4eb151",
      "observations_sha256": "721434f33edd45d32d381ac3976a1f63440ee0ce3d50abd887f20fecef85ecb6"
    },
    {
      "request_index": 8,
      "verdict": "keep",
      "reason": "Actual target tests report 70 passed; manual empty/mixed/Unicode checks pass. No test files are modified.",
      "assistant_sha256": "4acac1d6efcf39310af7fe5e832d499c269aa8967cc4d5cafe7fb23f0a310edc",
      "observations_sha256": "4b17fa0c0ba28d5e32a10416f6f6ff5534537b1705ac5a120f920456298baaf9"
    },
    {
      "request_index": 9,
      "verdict": "mask",
      "reason": "Mask nonincremental hypothetical hidden-test discussion after successful validation; actual diff remains available as context.",
      "assistant_sha256": "632a5829a04e52bc752d8a805c508e62e70e11a35c1b10f79e15bb7305b15ec4",
      "observations_sha256": "15661d209485357345432edc324dd566e251b1c35a829cffbd1a20c88f595990"
    },
    {
      "request_index": 10,
      "verdict": "mask",
      "reason": "Mask mixed final response with an unverified claim about the actual upstream PR. Reported tests are truthful; no external answer was retrieved.",
      "assistant_sha256": "0b600efaa21d5e72ec3c5fd4f8cf0af1cd6a905976044305769b213d83d91cd9",
      "observations_sha256": "4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945"
    }
  ],
  "tool_reviews": [
    {
      "call_id": "call_820ad7c569ea4733a5c84bff",
      "request_index": 1,
      "verdict": "keep",
      "reason": "Allowed declared-base status/history and local symbol search; no external answer."
    },
    {
      "call_id": "call_be1043713bc64dfd8bfa7d3e",
      "request_index": 1,
      "verdict": "keep",
      "reason": "Allowed declared-base status/history and local symbol search; no external answer."
    },
    {
      "call_id": "call_8a45824a54cb464e92b21c21",
      "request_index": 2,
      "verdict": "keep",
      "reason": "Observed existing template dispatch, lower/upper/title semantics and visible tests."
    },
    {
      "call_id": "call_e7dd4f6bcd6245f181d70852",
      "request_index": 2,
      "verdict": "keep",
      "reason": "Observed existing template dispatch, lower/upper/title semantics and visible tests."
    },
    {
      "call_id": "call_cf8058b3d9144144a109a0fb",
      "request_index": 3,
      "verdict": "keep",
      "reason": "Reads visible template tests and public documentation. Brief anticipated-test language does not replace the public feature requirement."
    },
    {
      "call_id": "call_4cd7c7e0ed2c436b91a5b717",
      "request_index": 3,
      "verdict": "keep",
      "reason": "Reads visible template tests and public documentation. Brief anticipated-test language does not replace the public feature requirement."
    },
    {
      "call_id": "call_8cbe3311c824410e9ead7744",
      "request_index": 4,
      "verdict": "mask",
      "reason": "Mask unnecessary guesses about the target PR implementation and hidden test names; public capitalize semantics already suffice."
    },
    {
      "call_id": "call_563574ad84624a7bab853359",
      "request_index": 4,
      "verdict": "mask",
      "reason": "Mask unnecessary guesses about the target PR implementation and hidden test names; public capitalize semantics already suffice."
    },
    {
      "call_id": "call_1db7e92066d442b5a9bcd2a3",
      "request_index": 5,
      "verdict": "mask",
      "reason": "All three edits fail the native read precondition. No files change; retain errors only as context."
    },
    {
      "call_id": "call_bc7744e7f40e400a8e501615",
      "request_index": 5,
      "verdict": "mask",
      "reason": "All three edits fail the native read precondition. No files change; retain errors only as context."
    },
    {
      "call_id": "call_7a03c3be10cf435d9af66e70",
      "request_index": 5,
      "verdict": "mask",
      "reason": "All three edits fail the native read precondition. No files change; retain errors only as context."
    },
    {
      "call_id": "call_70f792ea6ccd43bb9b981f78",
      "request_index": 6,
      "verdict": "keep",
      "reason": "Corrects the tool precondition using native read for the exact three edit targets."
    },
    {
      "call_id": "call_35406a6a3ace4cbe9728c129",
      "request_index": 6,
      "verdict": "keep",
      "reason": "Corrects the tool precondition using native read for the exact three edit targets."
    },
    {
      "call_id": "call_9f97ef240f984e2896d978e1",
      "request_index": 6,
      "verdict": "keep",
      "reason": "Corrects the tool precondition using native read for the exact three edit targets."
    },
    {
      "call_id": "call_b8a8799ab76d4325aba39293",
      "request_index": 7,
      "verdict": "keep",
      "reason": "Successful source and documentation edits implement the explicit public capitalize requirement using str.capitalize()."
    },
    {
      "call_id": "call_30d7b548502240e5b14c215b",
      "request_index": 7,
      "verdict": "keep",
      "reason": "Successful source and documentation edits implement the explicit public capitalize requirement using str.capitalize()."
    },
    {
      "call_id": "call_dc0260a3e19f441fa9a1a447",
      "request_index": 7,
      "verdict": "keep",
      "reason": "Successful source and documentation edits implement the explicit public capitalize requirement using str.capitalize()."
    },
    {
      "call_id": "call_23cfcddd74bd4679bf78fb7f",
      "request_index": 8,
      "verdict": "keep",
      "reason": "Actual target tests report 70 passed; manual empty/mixed/Unicode checks pass. No test files are modified."
    },
    {
      "call_id": "call_432eb3457a064fdc8b7b72a0",
      "request_index": 8,
      "verdict": "keep",
      "reason": "Actual target tests report 70 passed; manual empty/mixed/Unicode checks pass. No test files are modified."
    },
    {
      "call_id": "call_3e37b855a0fe46b1adaa91b7",
      "request_index": 9,
      "verdict": "mask",
      "reason": "Mask nonincremental hypothetical hidden-test discussion after successful validation; actual diff remains available as context."
    },
    {
      "call_id": "call_bfb8ffdaea86475d92b7d6d5",
      "request_index": 9,
      "verdict": "mask",
      "reason": "Mask nonincremental hypothetical hidden-test discussion after successful validation; actual diff remains available as context."
    }
  ],
  "new_model_or_judge_calls": 0,
  "limits": [
    "Existing valid independent judge, probe and alignment reused; no claim of model diversity."
  ]
}