{
  "schema_version": 1,
  "created_at": "2026-11-01T08:21:57.516609+00:00",
  "status": "independent_four_source_admission_review_complete",
  "scope": "Only the four completed P1 sources explicitly assigned by the user; beets5409 and later production are excluded.",
  "source_root": "E:\\Deeplearning\\local_train\\eval\\work\\teacher80-20261101",
  "source_manifest": {
    "path": "E:\\Deeplearning\\local_train\\eval\\work\\teacher80-20261101\\independent-review\\source-manifest.json",
    "sha256": "b4b7f07dfcc686106fcccfbc804f394b584ca20c507865953f6eb440cce7faf2"
  },
  "routing_compatibility_evidence_reused": {
    "path": "E:\\Deeplearning\\local_train\\eval\\work\\teacher80-20261101\\parent\\model-alias-compatibility.json",
    "sha256": "f106f112f56fe0f4541bfe43a76321197d936509b1b5b868337bf79477bcb139"
  },
  "reviewer_provenance": {
    "role_basis": "User assigned independent data-admission review to this existing Codex conversation.",
    "exact_runtime_session_id": null,
    "exact_runtime_model_id": null,
    "unverified_identity_not_claimed": true,
    "new_review_sessions_or_subagents": 0,
    "independent_of_initial_executor_review": "This pass re-read the complete traces; no separate-model consensus or vote is claimed."
  },
  "counts": {
    "sources": 4,
    "admit": 0,
    "admit_with_masks": 4,
    "quarantine": 0,
    "decisions_fully_reviewed": 59,
    "actual_tool_calls_fully_reviewed": 85,
    "mask_request_indices": 20,
    "already_zero_targets_among_masks": 2,
    "additional_positive_decisions_removed": 18,
    "positive_decisions_retained": 39,
    "preview_supervised_tokens": 28396,
    "recommended_retained_supervised_tokens": 11291,
    "removed_supervised_tokens": 17105,
    "sources_with_retained_core_edit_supervision": 3,
    "sources_without_retained_core_edit_supervision": 1
  },
  "sources": [
    {
      "instance_id": "msiemens_tinydb_pr39",
      "verdict": "admit_with_masks",
      "audit": {
        "path": "E:\\Deeplearning\\local_train\\storage\\audits\\teacher80-20261101\\review-msiemens_tinydb_pr39.json",
        "sha256": "bfedc8342899190352656176a526d323dbf23719fc1293ea04625357918cd2a7"
      },
      "decisions_reviewed": 9,
      "tools_reviewed": 14,
      "mask_requests": [
        6,
        8
      ],
      "already_automatic_zero_target_requests": [],
      "recommended_retained_target_tokens": 1192,
      "core_edit_supervised": false,
      "retained_core_edit_requests": []
    },
    {
      "instance_id": "lasp_cdflib_pr162",
      "verdict": "admit_with_masks",
      "audit": {
        "path": "E:\\Deeplearning\\local_train\\storage\\audits\\teacher80-20261101\\review-lasp_cdflib_pr162.json",
        "sha256": "2c95d947fd2b6c8cfdc08b93bc229afb5de5e3499e50deb69a499acbe2dbe306"
      },
      "decisions_reviewed": 22,
      "tools_reviewed": 29,
      "mask_requests": [
        1,
        6,
        7,
        9,
        10,
        12,
        16,
        19,
        20
      ],
      "already_automatic_zero_target_requests": [],
      "recommended_retained_target_tokens": 4195,
      "core_edit_supervised": true,
      "retained_core_edit_requests": [
        13
      ]
    },
    {
      "instance_id": "msiemens_tinydb_pr33",
      "verdict": "admit_with_masks",
      "audit": {
        "path": "E:\\Deeplearning\\local_train\\storage\\audits\\teacher80-20261101\\review-msiemens_tinydb_pr33.json",
        "sha256": "77340df086a840d2cbe1b31509655e0115e3dd6525fa288421ad0d34d8d8d0b5"
      },
      "decisions_reviewed": 14,
      "tools_reviewed": 24,
      "mask_requests": [
        4,
        5,
        8,
        9,
        14
      ],
      "already_automatic_zero_target_requests": [
        9
      ],
      "recommended_retained_target_tokens": 3827,
      "core_edit_supervised": true,
      "retained_core_edit_requests": [
        6
      ]
    },
    {
      "instance_id": "beetbox_beets_pr5442",
      "verdict": "admit_with_masks",
      "audit": {
        "path": "E:\\Deeplearning\\local_train\\storage\\audits\\teacher80-20261101\\review-beetbox_beets_pr5442.json",
        "sha256": "4f768aa11f2753a143836db04a1415edb856d6effb41b72cbca29a68f4637836"
      },
      "decisions_reviewed": 14,
      "tools_reviewed": 18,
      "mask_requests": [
        7,
        10,
        12,
        14
      ],
      "already_automatic_zero_target_requests": [
        7
      ],
      "recommended_retained_target_tokens": 2077,
      "core_edit_supervised": true,
      "retained_core_edit_requests": [
        9
      ]
    }
  ],
  "interpretation": [
    "No actual external/future answer retrieval is evidenced in the 85 tool observations. Self-attributed upstream-memory claims are not mislabeled as verified exposure.",
    "Specific future-answer seeking intentions, unverified implementation recollections, real tool-contract errors and nonincremental grader-focused repetition are masked at whole-decision granularity.",
    "Allowed base-history inspection and concrete publicly derived acceptance/rejection reasoning remain eligible; a git/hidden/upstream keyword alone does not decide a mask.",
    "TinyDB39 loses its only supervised edit at request 6 under these masks. It retains 1192 public diagnosis/verification/conclusion tokens and must not be described as retaining supervised patch-writing actions.",
    "Beets5442 honestly reports the obsolete visible-title assertion failure. Its independently passing judge/probe receipt is reused; no visible failure is hidden or recast as a pass."
  ],
  "accounting_method": "Token recommendations subtract whole-decision masks from existing token-alignment response_supervised_tokens, which sum exactly to the four parent candidate previews. No renderer or candidate export was rerun.",
  "existing_receipts_reused": {
    "official_judge_accepted_sources": 4,
    "fresh_before_sources": 4,
    "judge_cleanup_sources": 4,
    "public_probe_passed_sources": 4,
    "prefix_matches": 59
  },
  "originals_and_workers_unchanged": true,
  "new_model_calls": 0,
  "new_solver_calls": 0,
  "new_judge_calls": 0,
  "new_renderer_calls": 0,
  "new_tests_or_engineering_audits": 0,
  "candidate_or_original_review_overwritten": false,
  "committed": false,
  "pushed": false,
  "outputs_policy": "Each per-source audit and this aggregate were created once with exclusive file creation; original review/candidate/raw/protocol/provenance and services were untouched.",
  "next_step": "Parent applies the exact masks through the existing export/release workflow and makes composition decisions; this review does not alter the 80/20 recipe or add a new admission gate."
}