{
  "schema_version": 1,
  "role": "executor",
  "date": "2026-10-31",
  "training_eligible": false,
  "baseline": {
    "parent": "702be18138e81c9320a3e88bf29fdba5052c481c",
    "submodule": "c664ce51851e73ce94f599d918424dda329e6d62"
  },
  "commits": {
    "parent_code": "9ff2f970b7399ae84ef7a103d3e1b78f595faa0b",
    "branch": "quality-guards-probe-feedback",
    "submodule": [
      "8ca4edd restore_test_files fail-closed",
      "65fee6c2e11bad0dc6d04759047bde46588052e7 run_dsh_native --public-probe-freeze"
    ],
    "gitlink": "65fee6c2e11bad0dc6d04759047bde46588052e7",
    "pushed": false
  },
  "file_scope": {
    "A_restore": [
      "swefactory_self/aweagent/core/eval/utils.py",
      "swefactory_self/aweagent/core/eval/base.py",
      "swefactory_self/tests/core/test_restore_test_files.py",
      "swefactory_self/tests/core/test_enhancements.py"
    ],
    "B_probe": [
      "eval/swe/public_probe.py",
      "eval/scripts/budget_proxy.py",
      "eval/swe/native_task.py",
      "eval/plugins/swe-v3-control/index.mjs",
      "eval/profiles/swe-agent-v3-takeover-high-probe/*",
      "swefactory_self/tools/run_dsh_native.py",
      "storage/native_decisions.py"
    ],
    "C_policy": [
      "eval/swe/public_probe.py SOURCE_POLICY, appended to the prompt only under the probe protocol"
    ],
    "tests": [
      "eval/tests/test_public_probe.py",
      "eval/tests/public_probe_e2e_fixture.py",
      "eval/tests/fixtures/public_probe_wakeonlan.py",
      "eval/plugins/swe-v3-control/test/unit.test.mjs",
      "storage/tests/native_fixtures.py",
      "storage/tests/test_native_public_probe.py"
    ],
    "untouched": [
      "old P0/run/release/profile/data",
      "Markdown/HTML/HANDOFF",
      "docs/eval/2026-10-31-Harness设计与工具监督.html",
      "DSH runtime b150a551"
    ]
  },
  "implementation": {
    "A": {
      "restore_from": "git ls-tree HEAD (frozen base) filtered to tests/test/Test/Tests dirs and conftest.py/test_*.py/*_test.py",
      "missing_dirs": "normal: nothing listed, no error",
      "deleted_tests_and_fixtures": "git checkout HEAD -- NUL-split shlex-quoted paths with GIT_LITERAL_PATHSPECS=1 (spaces/Unicode safe)",
      "added_test_files": "untracked non-ignored test-surface files are removed; ignored files kept",
      "source_and_build_files": "never touched; pyproject/setup keep the patch changes",
      "verification": "git diff --quiet HEAD on restored paths and re-list of added files; any failure raises and the judge returns accepted=False",
      "receipt": "EvalResult.details.test_restore"
    },
    "B": {
      "protocol": "public-probe-feedback-v1",
      "opt_in": "profile swe-agent-v3-takeover-high-probe together with --public-probe-freeze; each refuses without the other; requires routed P1/P2/P3",
      "freeze": "python eval/swe/public_probe.py freeze --task-file T --instance-id ID --script S --output F (disposable --network none container on the clean base, receipt outside run dir)",
      "pre_call_check": "FrozenProbe verifies instance, script sha, case-list sha and rule, public task sha, image_id, base_commit, baseline_valid before any container or request; task rows with hidden fields are refused",
      "runtime": "plugin agent/turn-stopping with stopReason=stop -> POST {proxy}/public-probe -> ProbeController runs the frozen bytes via docker exec stdin python -B in the same task container",
      "feedback": "first failed valid run with budget >= minOutputTokens; only failing public cases id/input/expected/observed plus stderr tail; at most one per episode; later stops are terminal checks",
      "infra": "nonzero/timeout exit, unparsable output, probe_valid not true, case hash/id mismatch, workspace mutated by the probe, deadline -> no feedback and no pass",
      "terminal_verdict": "last valid run on the final workspace sha (post_exit probe when stale; skipped on task_timeout) else unverified",
      "receipts": [
        "protocol.json public_probe",
        "public-probe-runs.jsonl",
        "public-probe-raw/NN.json",
        "public-probe-feedback.json",
        "prediction.json public_probe_final"
      ],
      "data_gate": "native_decisions.check_probe_feedback: freeze present outside the run with the same sha, identity keys equal, <=1 feedback all delivered on the wire, last run passed on the final workspace; receipt and freeze added to candidate_evidence",
      "loss": "feedback is a plugin user notice like other control messages (loss=0); student token prefix unchanged"
    },
    "C": "SOURCE_POLICY allows problem statement, base source, visible tests, history reachable from base; forbids merged PR, future implementations, out-of-repo package copies, guessing hidden tests. No shell blacklist and no online LLM monitor; existing semantic review kept."
  },
  "tests": {
    "submodule_restore": "pytest tests/core/test_restore_test_files.py + test_restore_test_files_recursive_glob: 7 passed",
    "eval_unittest": "148 run; 2 errors in test_evalkit (ModuleNotFoundError lcb_runner, vendor not mounted in this worktree; unrelated); test_public_probe 8/8 ok",
    "storage_unittest": "66 run; 15 failures all blocked at loader stage with ImportError cannot import Dataset from datasets (no Python here has datasets); new PublicProbeFeedbackGateTests 3/3 ok",
    "plugin_node": "51 checks passed (5 new publicProbe checks)",
    "e2e_real_dsh_docker": {
      "log_dir": "E:\\Deeplearning\\local_train\\eval\\work\\quality-guards-20261031\\executor\\e2e-3",
      "summary_sha256": "9f742dab738b8344c2b66dc3dc02d50f3f562cc4ec8cc96099eca65af99925fb",
      "freeze": {
        "path": "E:\\Deeplearning\\local_train\\eval\\work\\quality-guards-20261031\\executor\\e2e-3\\freeze\\probe-freeze.json",
        "case_list_sha256": "72022b70d8833bfadd9dfba16ac12a6be2beec49146c869474a2eabcad28fb52",
        "baseline": [
          [
            "colon",
            true
          ],
          [
            "bare12",
            true
          ],
          [
            "dot",
            false
          ],
          [
            "bare14",
            true
          ]
        ],
        "elapsed_s": 0.11
      },
      "probe-fix": {
        "error": null,
        "terminal_status": "completed",
        "teacher_requests": 8,
        "fallback_requests": 0,
        "unused_script_replies": 0,
        "runs": [
          [
            1,
            "stop",
            "failed",
            true,
            0.11
          ],
          [
            2,
            "stop",
            "passed",
            false,
            0.11
          ]
        ],
        "feedback_count": 1,
        "feedback_delivered": [
          true
        ],
        "final_status": "passed",
        "passed": true,
        "history_kept": true,
        "feedback_in_final_context": true,
        "hidden_fields_absent": true,
        "protocol_public_probe": "72022b70d8833bfadd9dfba16ac12a6be2beec49146c869474a2eabcad28fb52",
        "cleanup_verified": true
      },
      "probe-correct": {
        "error": null,
        "terminal_status": "completed",
        "teacher_requests": 4,
        "fallback_requests": 0,
        "unused_script_replies": 0,
        "runs": [
          [
            1,
            "stop",
            "passed",
            false,
            0.12
          ]
        ],
        "feedback_count": 0,
        "feedback_delivered": [],
        "final_status": "passed",
        "passed": true,
        "history_kept": true,
        "feedback_in_final_context": false,
        "hidden_fields_absent": true,
        "protocol_public_probe": "72022b70d8833bfadd9dfba16ac12a6be2beec49146c869474a2eabcad28fb52",
        "cleanup_verified": true
      },
      "probe-repeat": {
        "error": null,
        "terminal_status": "completed",
        "teacher_requests": 6,
        "fallback_requests": 0,
        "unused_script_replies": 0,
        "runs": [
          [
            1,
            "stop",
            "failed",
            true,
            0.12
          ],
          [
            2,
            "stop",
            "failed",
            false,
            0.11
          ]
        ],
        "feedback_count": 1,
        "feedback_delivered": [
          true
        ],
        "final_status": "failed",
        "passed": false,
        "history_kept": true,
        "feedback_in_final_context": true,
        "hidden_fields_absent": true,
        "protocol_public_probe": "72022b70d8833bfadd9dfba16ac12a6be2beec49146c869474a2eabcad28fb52",
        "cleanup_verified": true
      },
      "tampered": {
        "rejected": true,
        "error": "public probe freeze rejected (E:\\Deeplearning\\local_train\\eval\\work\\quality-guards-20261031\\executor\\e2e-3\\tampered-freeze\\probe-freeze.json): ['script_sha256']",
        "requests_or_containers": []
      }
    },
    "raw_logs": "E:\\Deeplearning\\local_train\\eval\\work\\quality-guards-20261031\\executor"
  },
  "acceptance_map": {
    "normal_no_extra_correction": "probe-correct: one stop probe passed, 0 feedback",
    "real_failure_one_feedback_history_kept": "probe-fix: failed -> feedback delivered on wire -> fixed -> terminal passed",
    "repeat_no_loop": "probe-repeat: second identical failure gets no feedback, final failed",
    "budget_cancel_timeout": "unit: closed budget gate, abort, deadline and post_exit give no feedback; task_timeout skips post_exit",
    "tamper_identity_rejected": "tampered e2e plus unit cases (image/base/script/case/baseline/hidden fields)",
    "legit_git_not_rejected": "no shell restriction added; policy text permits git status/diff/log/blame",
    "restore_accurate_no_swallow": "submodule tests incl. Unicode/space paths and injected checkout/verify failures"
  },
  "performance": {
    "probe_elapsed_s": [
      0.11,
      0.11,
      0.12,
      0.12,
      0.11
    ],
    "freeze_baseline_elapsed_s": 0.11,
    "per_probe_extra": "1 docker exec probe (~0.1 s) + 2 workspace_state docker exec + 1 GET /budget + 1 POST /public-probe; no model tokens except the single feedback message"
  },
  "old_p0_lapse": [
    "plugin_sources_sha256 includes eval/swe/public_probe.py and changed index.mjs/budget_proxy.py/native_task.py, so runtime_identity changes",
    "the probe protocol uses a new profile name/sha, so acceptance_identity differs; old P0 receipts no longer validate; new P0 is left to Debug"
  ],
  "debug_entry": "E:/Deeplearning/local_train/.venv/Scripts/python.exe eval/tests/public_probe_e2e_fixture.py --out <new dir> --dsh-repo E:/Deeplearning/dsh-p0-runtime-20261030 --task-file E:/Deeplearning/local_train/eval/work/native-engineering-20261031/inputs/solver-task.jsonl [--scenario probe-fix|probe-correct|probe-repeat|tampered]",
  "limitations": [
    "probe scripts must be authored per task from the public statement; only the wakeonlan fixture exists",
    "the source policy is prompt-level and does not technically prevent answer seeking",
    "restore covers the conventional test surface; tests outside those names, or test monkeypatching from source, are not restored",
    "storage release/Arrow tests and evalkit could not run here (missing datasets/lcb_runner); the gate is tested through candidate_rows/candidate_evidence directly",
    "e2e uses scripted teacher upstreams; no real model/teacher, GPU, training or production run"
  ],
  "revision": [
    {
      "date": "2026-11-01",
      "scope": "parent-requested five confirmed gaps; no rerun of prior A/B/C",
      "source_test_commit": "5078cd7399209906a79eb739fdb25f8e39403929",
      "submodule_commit": "0fd0c899a665769e1228de877e8274ddd146d25f",
      "correction": {
        "supersedes": [
          "tests.storage_unittest missing datasets explanation",
          "limitations[3] storage release/Arrow unavailable"
        ],
        "statement": "The prior claim that no usable datasets environment existed was incorrect. Python312 with the supplied deps312 PYTHONPATH imports datasets and pyarrow 26.0.0, and the affected storage tests including real CPU Arrow export/load passed. The separate earlier lcb_runner limitation is not resolved or retested here.",
        "python": "C:/Users/wxq69/AppData/Local/Programs/Python/Python312/python.exe",
        "pythonpath": "C:/Users/wxq69/.lody/repos/local---45ff984dd1be/worktrees/aaf67afa-0371-435c-bdf4-6e2af3d1738c/eval/work/native-b/deps312"
      },
      "fixes": [
        "CLI routed defaults repaired; actual argument coverage for P1/P2/P3 with/without probe, explicit overrides, legacy; preflight pairing, outside-run freeze, inspected image identity and FrozenProbe checks; P2/P3 student prerequisite before readiness",
        "restore uses real git apply --numstat -z patch paths plus staged additions; removes ignored patch-added hook and indexed test paths; preserves untouched ignored fixture/cache and source changes",
        "publication independently hashes later user wire messages, rejects assistant/tool echo and absent delivery; terminal probe records the patch hash during execution and compares actual submitted model_patch",
        "public task allowlist and known private column rejection; clean HEAD/index/worktree before and after freeze; baseline definitions and cases evaluated through evaluate_run",
        "paired P0 source binding adds evaluator base.py and utils.py; public_probe remains in plugin source manifest; sealer verifies paired identity, task/freeze/script/case hashes, profile and feedback/patch contract and records probe evidence"
      ],
      "tests": {
        "affected_suite": "53 passed, 74 subtests passed in 53.62s",
        "final_boundary_changes": "26 passed, 12 subtests passed in 31.02s (CLI and P0 affected tests only; includes added production P2 prerequisite regression)",
        "real_scripted_dsh_cpu_docker": {
          "scenarios": [
            "probe-fix",
            "probe-correct"
          ],
          "model_calls": 0,
          "results": {
            "probe-fix": {
              "publish_gate": "passed",
              "submitted_patch_sha256": "c5d41e7fb0b7600eb5dcc6218eae81bc04f61a71e64e32c81a6a407aac884c4d",
              "feedback_count": 1,
              "terminal_status": "passed",
              "cleanup": true
            },
            "probe-correct": {
              "publish_gate": "passed",
              "submitted_patch_sha256": "c5d41e7fb0b7600eb5dcc6218eae81bc04f61a71e64e32c81a6a407aac884c4d",
              "feedback_count": 0,
              "terminal_status": "passed",
              "cleanup": true
            }
          },
          "note": "Runtime patch binding, user delivery and cleanup verified against actual wire. Subsequent strict baseline-schema checks were validated by targeted tests; this is not a new P0 acceptance. Raw fixture-summary hidden_fields_absent=false is the old substring checker matching model_patch_sha256; key-level independent check passed and Debug checker was corrected."
        },
        "logs": {
          "revision-targeted-final.log": {
            "path": "E:\\Deeplearning\\local_train\\eval\\work\\quality-guards-20261031\\executor\\revision-targeted-final.log",
            "sha256": "114a75f99300e10f82849a225740cff42455931d25533b4e8a75c435d3258cc7"
          },
          "revision-final-boundaries.log": {
            "path": "E:\\Deeplearning\\local_train\\eval\\work\\quality-guards-20261031\\executor\\revision-final-boundaries.log",
            "sha256": "19aa9b06b6dcb4b2c7815166ee52dc038ca0dbddb685c3c8e94b37f1f81ff270"
          },
          "e2e-revision.log": {
            "path": "E:\\Deeplearning\\local_train\\eval\\work\\quality-guards-20261031\\executor\\e2e-revision.log",
            "sha256": "77025d78d0c6255e6715ea59afa7d009816547f5cc52e55e1cb7a5cac9c6aa48"
          },
          "revision-publish-binding.log": {
            "path": "E:\\Deeplearning\\local_train\\eval\\work\\quality-guards-20261031\\executor\\revision-publish-binding.log",
            "sha256": "83e4124ee73328a0bbf860933bca072bcd1760dd0794baf4e79bc444938ea7d9"
          }
        }
      },
      "debug_entry": "C:/Users/wxq69/AppData/Local/Programs/Python/Python312/python.exe eval/tests/public_probe_e2e_fixture.py --out <new-dir> --dsh-repo E:/Deeplearning/dsh-p0-runtime-20261030 --task-file E:/Deeplearning/local_train/eval/work/native-engineering-20261031/inputs/solver-task.jsonl [--scenario probe-fix|probe-correct|probe-repeat|tampered]",
      "constraints": {
        "local_commits_only": true,
        "pushed": false,
        "merged_to_main": false,
        "new_p0_sealed": false,
        "real_model_teacher_training_gpu_production": false,
        "other_agents_spawned": false,
        "markdown_html_handoff_memory_modified": false
      },
      "limitations": [
        "No new engineering P0 was fabricated; Debug must generate and seal fresh paired evidence on the final source identities.",
        "Restore protects the existing conventional test surface; source-level test monkeypatching remains outside that scope.",
        "Source policy remains prompt-level. No new training benefit or real-model performance claim."
      ],
      "performance": "Probe elapsed 0.11-0.12s in scripted runs; one additional collect_patch docker exec per probe plus read-only freeze cleanliness checks; publish wire hashing is linear in captured requests."
    }
  ]
}