{
  "schema_version": 1,
  "status": "parent_Codex_reconciliation_complete",
  "instance_id": "meerk40t_svgelements_pr233",
  "reviewed_on": "2026-11-01",
  "reviewer": {
    "kind": "Codex parent",
    "session_id": "f9bb1ad1-7bb6-4573-84c2-959375914d02"
  },
  "late_review": {
    "path": "E:\\Deeplearning\\local_train\\eval\\work\\p2p3-real-20261101\\recovery-1\\postprocess\\meerk40t_svgelements_pr233\\executor-semantic-summary.json",
    "sha256": "f76bd427cc6f6f45c9b3b07cf9c840ef41a6657f061a2768e1ca502e6f31cac0"
  },
  "original_review": {
    "path": "E:\\Deeplearning\\local_train\\eval\\work\\p2p3-real-20261101\\recovery-1\\production\\part1\\runs\\meerk40t_svgelements_pr233\\review.json",
    "sha256": "3e17c8efef171ac25c79d07985b08292530fd52fcab9be7b144e72ef4d58b862"
  },
  "original_candidate": {
    "path": "E:\\Deeplearning\\local_train\\eval\\work\\p2p3-real-20261101\\recovery-1\\postprocess\\meerk40t_svgelements_pr233\\candidate.json",
    "sha256": "b82a380e9db8d285b19727b9458079a9ab99f84001f7a925937be89a41a4c82f"
  },
  "original_release": {
    "path": "E:\\Deeplearning\\local_train\\eval\\work\\p2p3-real-20261101\\recovery-1\\published\\release\\release.json",
    "sha256": "2a56f45c658c19ac9b3bb2456b3351367eac81f7fce9c51fe8955c6c339b3781"
  },
  "accepted_positive_target_removals": [
    21,
    25,
    27,
    28,
    29,
    32,
    38,
    47,
    50
  ],
  "rejected_mask_recommendations": [
    {
      "request_index": 34,
      "reason": "The corrected git log reads only history reachable from the declared base. No reasoning asserts a future answer, and no future content is observed. Allowed base-history inspection is retained."
    },
    {
      "request_index": 37,
      "reason": "The response explicitly dismisses the hypothetical grader preference, then derives exact boundary selection from the public npoint==point requirement and visible implementation; the baseline test passes."
    },
    {
      "request_index": 49,
      "reason": "The action verifies the public issue path with exact equality at three sample densities. The incidental hidden-test guess supplies no answer and does not replace the public acceptance criterion."
    }
  ],
  "final_mask_requests": [
    6,
    7,
    8,
    9,
    10,
    11,
    12,
    13,
    15,
    18,
    19,
    20,
    21,
    22,
    25,
    27,
    28,
    29,
    31,
    32,
    33,
    35,
    38,
    39,
    40,
    42,
    47,
    50,
    51,
    52,
    56,
    57
  ],
  "findings": [
    "Request 47 fails inside the comparison helper with TypeError: NoneType is not iterable; this failed action must not have positive loss.",
    "Request 50 uses Hidden tests likely valid to decide whether to guard a boundary; mask its mixed response.",
    "Requests 21/25/27/28/29/32/38 read files using shell commands contrary to the captured system read-tool rule, before the UTF-8 limitation was established.",
    "A failed correctness test is not automatically an invalid action. Request 51 exposes a real defect; its manual mask is for mixed speculative reasoning, and it was already structurally zero due to length.",
    "All student decisions remain zero loss. Core repair 43 remains positive; final boundary correction 52 remains zero."
  ],
  "counts": {
    "old_teacher_supervised_tokens": 13323,
    "expected_teacher_supervised_tokens": 9217,
    "removed_supervised_tokens": 4106,
    "expected_supervised_decisions": 14,
    "retained_core_edit_tokens": 1413
  },
  "new_model_calls": 0,
  "new_judge_calls": 0,
  "new_renderer_calls": 0,
  "rubric": {
    "path": "E:\\Deeplearning\\local_train\\eval\\work\\p2p3-real-20261101\\parent\\review-rubric.json",
    "sha256": "3cddb1aef413bfa8ca01eca250e31c2caebfc866f013b03acd4be4403d031a33"
  }
}